How the value of cardholder data is changing the economics of rewards
/Shawn Conahan is chief revenue officer of Wildfire Systems, a white-label cashback and shopping rewards loyalty platform.
Every time a cardholder redeems a merchant offer, the bank learns something advertisers will pay for: which offers lead to a sale. Banks can use that purchase history to show a merchant’s next offer to likely buyers and charge the merchant to reach them.
That ad revenue takes on new importance as interchange fees, a traditional source of funding for card rewards, come under pressure.
Banks and card networks sell those ads through financial media networks (FMNs), which let merchants track the sales their campaigns generate. Banks should use a share of their FMN revenue to fund the rewards that bring cardholders back to merchant offers.
Mastercard says its commerce media network delivers up to 22x return on ad spend (ROAS). American Express shared that Tumi's pilot on its new Amex Ads platform beat the brand's own ROAS benchmark by 30%. And Chase reports that Chase Offers, the customer-facing rewards program behind Chase Media Solutions, drove $11.2 billion in spend to participating merchants in 2025.
What makes this incredible performance possible?
Rewards are the engine behind financial media networks
The answer ties back to the use of loyalty and rewards programs to drive customer behavior and generate insights for better targeting capabilities. For example, Chase Media Solutions campaigns run as Chase Offers. Mastercard's network relies on purchase data to deliver high-intent audiences to advertisers. Amex describes Amex Ads as building on the foundation of its Amex Offers rewards program, using first-party transaction and travel purchase history to target customers.
Rewards give customers a reason to engage and advertisers a way to measure the response to their offers.
Most midsize banks and credit unions don’t operate media networks of their own. Many do offer merchant-funded rewards through third-party offer platforms, fintech partners, or credit union service organizations, often with a share of the revenue flowing back to the institution.
Regardless of their scale or how they deliver offers, every financial institution earning revenue from merchant offers or media networks and leveraging data to improve targeting faces the same question: How does a bank keep funding the rewards programs that make its member data so valuable to advertisers in the first place?
The erosion of interchange as a funding source
Historically, interchange fees have funded credit card rewards. But with growing legal and regulatory pressure on the credit card industry, interchange fees could soon become a far less reliable funding source for rewards programs. The still pending Credit Card Competition Act (CCCA) would require large card issuers to enable at least two unaffiliated payment networks for every credit card, giving merchants the power to choose how transactions are routed. This could push interchange fees lower and significantly reduce a key income stream for banks.
We have historical precedent to see how this can play out: after the Durbin amendment capped the rates issuers could charge for debit interchange fees, debit rewards programs mostly disappeared.
If rewards shrink, engagement will follow, and so will the behavioral insights and targeting capabilities that make an investment in an FMN campaign worthwhile. Media network revenue depends on rewards programs, which need a funding source that's more reliable than just interchange fees. The smart move would be to connect them.
Connecting the two lines of business is a better approach than keeping them separate and the revenue attribution vague. To that end, reinvesting FMN revenue into member rewards creates a self-propagating loop: continued valuable rewards drive more offer activation and engagement. More engagement generates more shopping and behavioral insights about customers. Better targeting capabilities improve advertiser ROAS, which in turn creates more advertiser demand and allows for richer pricing by the financial institution. Here are a few ways to build that flywheel:
Put revenue and rewards on the same ledger. If FMN income lands in a corporate "other revenue" line while rewards sit as a cost center in the card P&L, nobody has a reason to reinvest the FMN revenue. Institutions should define how much FMN revenue flows back to the loyalty budget and explicitly attribute it there so the connection shows up in planning rather than relying on goodwill between teams.
Organize around the customer, not the product. Most banks are siloed by product line, often with separate systems of record inherited through acquisitions. But an FMN, executed right, can “see” the whole customer. The rewards the media network funds should as well, recognizing a member's full relationship across debit, credit, and lending rather than activity on a single card.
Protect the value exchange. Advertisers value these audiences because members engage with offers they genuinely find useful. But if customers believe their bank is monetizing their behavior without giving them value in return, that willingness to participate in offers declines, and data quality erodes. Reinvesting in rewards is part of what keeps the exchange fair.
Get transparency from network partners. For institutions working through a third-party platform, rev-share terms, reporting on how much revenue member data generates, and the flexibility to direct that revenue into rewards should be negotiated up front.
The asset is customer engagement
The companies touting their remarkable FMN results certainly have good reason to. But the true asset behind those outcomes is member engagement with rewards, and that engagement has to be funded somehow. As interchange becomes less dependable, the longest-lasting funding source for rewards may be the revenue those rewards already generate through advertiser investment in the network. Organizations need to look at restructuring the business now so the connection between rewards, engagement, and higher media network revenue is explicit before the math behind revised interchange rates forces them to.